The recently published list of the top 10 Korean dramas of 2025 voted by fans on KingChoice with 98,180 votes has stirred heated debate among the K‑drama community. The most shocking outcome: the number‑one spot goes to When the Stars Gossip, a series many criticized as “a television disaster,” while When Life Gives You Tangerines regarded by many as an emotional masterpiece only lands at number 4. The disconnect between critical acclaim and fandom’s power has turned the ranking into a lightning rod for controversy.
1. When the Stars Gossip
Centering on a romance between a space tourist and an astronaut on a space station, the show features grand visuals and slick special effects. Yet many criticized its disjointed plot, uneven pacing, and confusing story beats. Thanks to massive fan support especially for its stars the drama still clinched the top spot. Its win has made When the Stars Gossip one of the most contentious Korean dramas of 2025: visually stunning, but arguably not deserving of the crown based on quality alone.
2. Dear X
A psychological thriller following celebrated actress Baek Ah Jin (Kim Yoo Jung), who hides a violent past and ruthless ambition behind a perfect façade. The show reflects the dark underbelly of the entertainment industry, full of secrets and power plays, and reveals the price of fame.
3. Genie, Make a Wish
A romantic drama infused with modern‑mythical elements, telling the story of a real-life “genie” and a human whose wishes remain unfulfilled. It delivers a gentle yet deep emotional experience humorous, romantic, and slightly fantastical ideal for viewers wanting warmth without heavy drama.
4. When Life Gives You Tangerines
Regarded as 2025’s emotional blockbuster, this film‑like drama set on Jeju Island explores life, love, and memory. Praised for its beautiful cinematography, evocative music, subtle performances, and lingering emotional impact, many argue it remains the year’s most artistically impressive Korean drama even if it only placed fourth among fan votes.
5. Newtopia
A mix of romance, fantasy, and slice‑of‑life, Newtopia follows two young individuals searching for meaning in a world both familiar and magical. With thoughtful settings, rich visuals, and emotionally evocative soundtracks, the story unfolds slowly, drawing viewers into its immersive, atmospheric world.
6. Good Boy
An action‑thriller about a group of former athletes confronting crime to protect their loved ones. The series impresses with high‑intensity chase scenes and tight action sequences, softened by moments of ordinary life offering an experience that’s both suspenseful and emotionally resonant.
7. Weak Hero: Class 2
The second season delves into school violence, social and family pressures, and peer dynamics. Known for its gritty realism, balanced portrayal of violence, and intense pacing, it keeps viewers on edge a powerful but heavy watch not for the faint‑hearted.
8. The Manipulated
A dark crime‑drama centered on Park Tae Joong (played by Ji Chang Wook), an ordinary man falsely accused and imprisoned by a conspiracy orchestrated by Ahn Yo Han (Do Kyung Soo). Upon release, Tae Joong seeks revenge, justice, and the truth. The tightly woven plot, psychological tension, and action make it a favorite among fans of crime and thriller genres.
9. Squid Game 3
The third season continues the deadly games with expanded political conspiracy and a deeper power structure behind the scenes. Led by returning Lee Jung Jae and the chilling presence of Lee Byung Hun, this season is lauded for brutal challenges, tense pacing, creative cinematography, and striking visuals arguably darker and more sophisticated than previous seasons.
10. Bon Appétit, Your Majesty
A historical drama blending royal court intrigue with culinary artistry. Featuring Yoona as a palace chef, with Lee Chae Min and Kang Han Na adding layers of political tension and drama, the show uses lavish royal cuisine not just as decor but as a storytelling device. Balanced between emotion, power, and artistry, it offers viewers both spectacular visuals and compelling narrative.
Sources: K14